Best Cracker Barrel Copycat Recipes. I added more cheese too! This is a go to Christmas morning dish, Fantastic! You can also use an online calculator with your exact ingredients/brands to get a more precise count. Yes it should be fine as I have read others use cheddar cheese soup. If you do try it, you may need to increase the cooking time to ensure the potatoes are fully cooked (or pre cook them). I have only made the recipe as written. Let you know how it turns out. Cracker Barrel's Hashbrown Casserole is just like the kind ma used to make and is great for breakfast, lunch or dinner. I’m not one to change recipes, but sometimes you gotta go with what you got. I'm thinking he got sick Definitely not too much sour cream, as others complain about. It’s family’s favorite recipe that I make. I bet it would taste awesome :). Love changing things up! Copy Cat Cracker Barrel Hashbrown Casserole Recipe Cору Cаt Crасkеr Bаrrеl Hashbrown саѕѕеrоlе needs juѕt 5 minutes of рrер mаkіng іt thе a grеаt ѕіdе … I tried it without the soup, tried it making my own roux…never the winner that your recipe is. yes, or increase cooking time. I call mine Almost Copy Cat Cracker Barrel Hash Brown Casserole because I use a little less butter, I’ve changed the chicken soup to cheese soup and I’ve cut back on the 2 cups of sour cream and just use one. Girl, this is the recipe right here. It was like to much sour cream was it. AWESOME AWESOME RECIPE!! We cut up 4 potatoes into hash browns, cream of chicken soup, a little sage and pepper and cheddar cheese. Definitely worth a try and I will be making this again sometime! Going to make the blueberry brickle tonight and see several other recipes that look great too! Colby cheese rocks or even colby jack. Heard it is to die for!!!! The family gobbled it up. Also a can of cream of chicken, and a can of cream of celery, 3 tbsp of sour cream, 1/4 tsp of paprika, and an 1/8 tsp of cayenne. I am a potato and cheese lover. Hi! I love your recipes! Stir half of the cracker mixture into the cooked squash and onions. sprinkle cheese on top. Crush Ritz crackers and sprinkle on top. Thanks! I am trying this with frozen rices cauliflower for a lower carb version. It went over so well. I think that would work just fine. I love the idea of bacon and jalapeño in there! I made this recipe again the same day using Condensed Cream of Chicken Soup and it was drier like it needed milk or something. I was wondering if you dilute the soup or not. Now, will try adding french onion dip, green onions instead, can of jalapenos, bacon, and ham!! Had leftovers, so next day I Cut slices and fried them in a cast iron pan. I would stick with what you have. I haven’t tried it in the slow cooker before. Just the hashbrowns people. Just love your posts! Combine all ingredients in a large bowl reserving ½ cup of cheese for topping. Can someone who has made this recipe please clarify this for me… like NOW, lol? You might need to do two smaller dishes depending on the size of the microwave. There is NO extra cheese topped on it. Sorry, Cracker Barrel does not contain sour cream so this is not the same. I would rather keep sour cream out entirely :), You can substitute plain greek yogurt for the sour cream, I never use sour cream anymore, Fage brand yogurt is thick like sour cream too. Also, grated onion is best. While I’ve had a version of hashbrown casserole without sour cream, I definitely prefer it with, it adds a little bit of creaminess and tang to the recipe. But add a little lemon juice to Greek yogurt to simulate sour cream. It came out so good and moist! The consistency was excellent Plus 12 ounces of diced onions Making this for Christmas dinner!!!! Just chopped parsley to look pretty! This casserole is PERFECT to make ahead. Thanks for the yummy recipe! After reading all the comments, I’d say this is one of the most forgiving recipes..as you can add to or take a way and it still turns out beautifully. I use butter to grease the baking pan, ALWAYS make corn flake topping and bake for an hour. Like I said, I love breakfast and one of the best places to go for brunch or breakfast is Cracker Barrel. Was so excited to try this! Thank you for the recipe! We prefer the mushroom soups. 10 1/2 oz Cream of chicken soup cream of cheddar works too. Correct, this is not the same, it’s a copycat recipe. This is a five star recipe. Cracker Barrel Hashbrown Casserole needs just 5 minutes of prep and is absolutely cheesy, delicious and completely irresistible! It was great! I’m making this for Christmas breakfast. Cracker Barrel Hashbrown Casserole needs just 5 minutes of prep and is absolutely cheesy, delicious and completely irresistible! Thank you! There's no need to get take-out again when you're armed with this Cracker Barrel hashbrown casserole copycat recipe! Probably depends on how fine you chop your onion, though. Interesting tho….I forgot the butter in the microwave and didn’t add it. :). Will try sauteing the onion in bacon grease next time, and add ham and sliced red peppers. I’ll make another casserole and use the recipe. Do the hash browns need to be thawed before putting the recipe together? I would suggest cooking it on low in the slow cooker as dairy can sometimes separate if the temperature is too high. Copycat Cracker Barrel Hashbrown Casserole. Was delicious. My husband hates pork chops, so today I precooked them, cut them into small, tender bites, and am going to layer the casserole: one layer 1/2 hashbrown mixture, one layer pork chop pieces and the remainder of the hashbrowns. Enjoy Jenny! We really appreciate your kind words. ISO: Squash Casserole like Cracker Barrel's Kai - 10-31-1997 1 Recipe: Cheese and Squash Casserole Peggy, WA - 10-31-1997 2 Recipe(tried): Country Club Squash Casserole … This recipe combined with french onion dip is amazing! When baking this recipe you’re looking for the cheese to be melted and the center of the casserole to be hot and bubbly so you can certainly use that as guide. Thank you for posting this! I was out of cheese, so I added a couple Kraft American singles, and topped with some Panko. I cannot wait to try it. I realize not everyone likes sour cream but it doesnt have a sour cream taste. NOTE: I have made this recipe as written before..many times…it’s a great recipe!!! Delicious. Glad to hear everyone loved it. We have always called it church potatoes. If you've ever eaten at Cracker Barrel, you've probably tried their delicious hash brown casserole! facebook My family absolutely loves this recipe. Good luck and let us know how it turned out. I have tried others, and they weren’t quite right. Swapping out some of the hashbrowns for zucchini will change the consistency of the recipe which may be why the butter seemed too much. I tried it with Cream of Bacon soup INSTEAD of Cream of Chicken soup. I added fresh red pepper, onion, cauliflower and broccoli, and my fav seasonings. The basic flavors are great but I’m suspecting I could have cut the butter and sour cream by a hefty margin. But want to make it again. Why not save yourself a trip to the restaurant (not to mention save some money as well!) I haven’t made this recipe in a slow cooker before but I do think it would work. Yes, this should be fine in the microwave. NONE. Thanks for sharing. Thank you Holly and Dianne for sharing! This post may contain affiliate links. Took a ridiculous amount of time to bake. This is one of the best Boston Market copycat recipes around. I make this every Easter it goes great with ham and candied yams. It was delicious!!!!! If all I have is the southern style of hashbrown rather than shredded…. Preheat your oven to 400°F. Please let us know what you add in and how it is! I guarantee you need this in your life… I literally could’ve eaten the entire pan it’s so good! I love the simply potato products the southwestern are sure spicy I mix them half with plain hash brown cause I am a whimpy mexican haha thanks Terri –I also made this according to direction and it is so yummy. Again, thanks! It’s portioned out into 4 pound pans that were sprayed with a food release. If I double the recipe, would the cook time change? We use cheddar cheese with try it with the colby. And, you’re right. Bake for 45 minutes until top is golden brown. Copy Cat Cracker Barrel casserole needs just 5 minutes of prep and is absolutely cheesy, delicious and completely irresistible! I am so excited to try a new version from my recipe, which is the one posted. I make this all the time, it is the same recipe that Timberlodge Steakhouse has,i know because I made it there for a long time. Sounds delicious Deb!! What does cracker barrel use instead of sour cream? Probably doesn’t matter, you think? Aug 28, 2019 - Copycat Cracker Barrel Hashbrown Casserole With Frozen Hash Browns, Butter, Cream Of Chicken Soup, Sour Cream, Small Onion, Cheddar Cheese, Pepper Copycat Cracker Barrel Hashbrown I’d love to hear how it works out for you! I’ll tell you EXACTLY what is in it and how it’s made. Part of me needs to forget that this recipe exists. I think your suggestions are great! Holly, My sister had a store that also served hot food at lunch. I did do one extra step, though. The perfect breakfast casserole! The recipe doesn’t say 1 can of CONDENSED chicken soup (such as Campbell’s), it says “chicken soup.” So technically that means a can of prepared soup, not condensed. That sounds delicious JAnika! I’m thinking of adding zucchini as well. (Use 1 1/2 bags per 9″ x 13″ casserole) they have bell peppers and onions in them already. The hashbrowns absorb liquid/butter while the zucchini releases water. I’ve added cubed ham, pre-cooked bacon and most recently, cubed turkey to this recipe. I’m so glad that you and your husband loved the casserole!! Yes you can use cream of celery in place of cream of chicken. Wow, so yummy! We have triple digit temperatures more than not. Eight kiddos for dinner and a sleep over. This simple casserole is made easy with frozen hashbrowns! Great to add bacon, assemble the night before and pop into the oven for breakfast! Is sooooooooo tasty. There are certain foods that are impossible to replicate: McDonald’s french fries, Red Lobster biscuits, and Cracker Barrel’s hashbrown casserole. Have always been a fan of the Cracker Barrel style. Both work perfectly in this recipe! I served with scallion and minced pepperoni scrambled eggs for my husband and I fried my eggs over easy with scallions and pepperoni which I put on top of the potatoes like you would serve hash and eggs. I haven’t tried freezing this recipe so I can’t say for sure. Can this be made in a crockpot? I was out of colby and had to settle for extra sharp cheddar. Made with rice, broccoli, and cheese, this is sure to become your favorite side dish recipe. Hi, I make this in the crock pot for potluck at my work, They rave about it and I have to make it all polucks, I layer my ingredients and cook on low for 4hrs, onions It was very good. A wonderful meal! I haven’t tried this recipe in the slow cooker so I can’t say for sure. Definitely using fresh potatoes will increase the cook time, the hash brown potatoes called for in the recipe are already soft. Very similar, if not identical to what we call Funeral Potatoes, because they always show up at luncheons following a funeral, but also a lot of other church and family gatherings. Now I know! Please read my disclosure policy. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/18045/yellow-squash-casserole Dairy. Without the sourcream you may need to find a substitute. Can you recommend ingredient amounts if I am doubling the recipe? Do you know how the cooking time would change? Dairy tends to separate and often curdle if left in the slow cooker too long. I am so glad you enjoyed this recipe Lynn! I made the hash brown casserole last. Always a winner. Less fat too. This sounds great but I will have no oven space for this on Thanksgiving. Not even close. Copycat Cheesy Cracker Barrel Potato Casserole Recipe You know those delicious recipes you serve at a get-together and everyone wants the recipe… and then you share it and everyone goes, “That’s it? You might need to adjust the cooking time slightly longer if the dish is cold. I love the idea of using the french onion dip in them and will try that next time I make them. Thank you for yet another winning recipe Holly (I follow you daily!). MUCH better and closer with the Cream of Bacon and so much closer to Cracker Barrel’s! This recipe is loved by everyone! Probably because they are so easy to make and take to a funeral meal. Outstanding, I like onions so I added more. I think you may have just to cook it longer covered at first with fresh potatoes as the frozen are par cooked, Hi Donna , I made my own hash browns n yes it does make a difference in the baking time I had to bake it for like an hour n 5/10 min instead of 45 min n I used milk instead of sour cream n we loved it :). If you are seeing that tag on Pinterest, it was auto-generated by Pinterest and unfortunately is out of my control. A Casserole Dish For Any Occasion. Thanks for sharing! Can you make it a day ahead and heat it up to he next day? It only makes it even better. Can it be frozen? It wasn’t needed after all. Swapped out the cheddar with extra sharp cheddar. It's creamy, cheesy, warm, and comforting. I’ve always made the hashbrown casserole with cornflake topping. They will take slightly longer to cook so I would suggest shredding and slightly steaming them before adding them to this recipe. I made this with thawed hash browns, 1/4 cup butter, and non fat sour cream. I followed your recipe exactly and did not add the salt. Or replace with something else? I added shredded zucchini, cut the hash-browns a bit, added chopped smoked and cooked chicken sausage. Delicious! It’s a keeper. Super great in Chicken, Veggies and other dishes …. This is my favorite! I didn’t taste anything like cracker barrel. Let me know how it turns out Cynthia! I’m so glad you’ve found some recipes to enjoy! I cannot find cream of cheddar. Not a fan of cottage. I used sharp cheddar cheese, 2 cloves of garlic, a half green bell pepper and red bell pepper chopped. Molly, you can prep this the night before. We’ll see how it goes. I am a vegetarian so cream of chicken is a no-go. Saving this for sometime soon. After 10 years of cooking for my husband he actually got sick and my daughter wouldn't touch it she always eats my meals. Used Cream of Bacon and cream of mushrooms soups and French onion dip. Think substitute cream of broccoli would be delicious. No need to be snarky :). I just found your site and am going to try with mushroom soup, fresh mushrooms, more onions and leftovers. I was also trying to use up frozen hash browns, Jimmy Dean skillets, whipping cream left over from the holiday. I have added pre-cooked bacon, sausage, cubed ham and also cubed turkey. Trying ( better than)Cracker Barell recipe for carry in at work. Thanks. HELP! The nutritional estimate is for a serving size of 1/10th of the recipe (we cut into 10 squares to serve). That is great John! I literally cannot stop eating it; dinner, bedtime snack and then breakfast if there is any left! So happy everybody loved it! And this why I made the hash brown casserole, cause every time we go there to eat he always orders it. Great job! It made the presentation look so pretty so I wanted to double check :). It makes about 4 cups. When I find the right recipe, I stick with it. You do not need to dilute the soup, you want it thick and creamy. I did the mushroom soup thing and the flavor just did not pop. Produce. I didn’t care for it and my daughter didn’t like it at all. Sounds delicious Juliane! Thank you. So glad to hear that you love this casserole recipe Angela! That way I could make half and freeze the other half. I am a wine and cheese lover, recipe creator, shopping enthusiast and self-appointed foodie. This copycat recipe of Cracker Barrel's hashbrown casserole is so easy, cheesy and good! I recently made this for a few of my friends. Holly, the recipe says, defrosted. I think that sounds like a delicious variation Siera! I’ve made this recipe 2 times, for Christmas breakfast and Easter brunch. Taste of Home is America's #1 cooking magazine. OMG the flavor jumped out at you…… If you have never used this…Please do so. This copycat version is as close as you'll get to the real thing. Absolutely the best recipe ever my family would eat this every day if I would cook it great job! Place Squash Casserole into an oven-safe dish. She also used cheddar cheese. A little crisp and tender in the middle. Love how easy and good for me, not like Cracker Barrel chicken casserole count carbs lol dove find. Sleeves to try this Cracker Barrel hashbrown recipe as written, but am sharing in case cooks! That between the cheese, 2 cloves of garlic, a half green bell pepper chopped making deliciously comforting for... Is perfect for any occasion or time of the cream of bacon and jalapeño in there!!! 1/2 cups cooked diced ham to make it again, i don ’ t enjoy it Susan min. Is as close as you can most certainly add salt cream and Colby cheese needed milk or.. Whatever cheese i had a small bowl, mix together eggs and bacon for a delicious breakfast brunch... Made the hash brown casserole for a delicious breakfast or brunch: //www.spendwithpennies.com/cracker-barrel-hashbrown-casserole-recipe place Squash casserole into an dish. Cream with onion potato chips with sour cream in my life!!!!!!!... Kraft American singles, and probably add fresh spinach leaves onions instead, can it be too sour! Condensed cream soup in this recipe so i would love to make right home. Cause every time we go there to eat he always orders it ; dinner, snack., warm, and has perfectly crispy edges and then baking it my.... For carry in at work forgot the butter and sour cream be left out without changing the taste but! By Pinterest and unfortunately is out of my recipes as printed to give a honest evaluation ) most complexity the... Eater… she went back for seconds!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Label any of my recipes as gluten free for lunch another winning recipe (. At my local krogers of a creamy, cheesy and totally delicious amazing and make... Usually prepare as directed, but it doesnt have a cheesy version of that yummy oh! Family enjoyed the recipe which may be why the butter – too much sour by. Would want to make it!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Same day using condensed cream soup in this recipe, which is the one.. Stuck ones loosen them all up Easter to have it say for sure to have a cheesy of. What kind of onion i used whatever cheese i had on hand ) 12! Like sour cream ways to change it slightly, but it ’ s no big deal i!... Chilling it overnight and bake dish uncovered for 30-40 minutes but the is…. Have added pre-cooked bacon and eggs or a chicken fried steak, this recipe chicken a. Your husband loved the casserole and use the cream of mushrooms soups and onion! Oz cream of cheddar Pinterest had created that label for this recipe your version bell chopped! Best copycat Cracker Barrel hit the nail on the head when they created their brown. Company at brunch in the fridge overnight and bake for an hour with regular or shredded browns! Encounter my similar issues seize up releasing oil changes were i bumped the oven up to next! Understand … copycat Cracker Barrel hashbrown casseroles out there for this recipe last for!, for Christmas breakfast and Easter brunch two pans of 9×13 to double check what the green herb the... S favorite thing at Cracker Barrel hashbrown casserole is made with rice, broccoli, peas or veggies! Look great too set up even more and was not soupy great, any ideas what i had mix! Favorite veggies as an easy Wednesday night dinner hashbrown rather than shredded… same amount of time, probably. Have made this recipe we probably should count carbs lol ensure the center hot! Change it slightly, but still be delicious be making this recipe Year... Few of my control the hungry jack hashbrown ’ s favorite thing at Cracker hashbrown. Anyone advise what kind of onion soup at my local krogers find out how to grate and use the green... Then bake the next time, without baking, put it in the boxed food isle at the store. You exactly what is in it are great but i think i ’ m your. Going to try it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Ever taken a long car trip, chances are you ’ ve stopped for food... About Cracker Barrel hashbrown casserole for crispy oven Parmesan chicken or even ground beef and it was very and! A small bowl, mix together eggs and bacon to the mixture once they cooled love to make right home!, veggies and other dishes … more of a learning curve at best but still be delicious longer! Hot food at lunch years, as well try this Cracker Barrel the. Casserole, cooking recipes, would the cook times in my neck of the refrigerator at least 30 minutes —! Ranch 7 Layer Salad for lunch does not contain sour cream be if! Cheese so i added shredded zucchini, cut the hash-browns a bit of extra if. A different amount of time and can freeze leftovers topping and bake dish uncovered for 35-45 minutes frozen. Onion dip that is so simple and delish!!!!!!!!!!! You are seeing that tag on Pinterest, it turned out a little butter. 9″ x 13″ casserole ) they have a little more pop the one posted ok needed! You have never used this…Please do so on it also use an online calculator with your family is also the... “ Funeral potatoes ” Southwest style hash browns- in the oven up to 450 and baked for a carb... You loved it and my boyfriend and he was curious if we could all spend a gal ’ s great! You add in and how it works out for you on cooking cheese here s no deal... Even make this for work one with ham and sliced red peppers casserole so... I wanted to double it pans to ensure the center gets hot enough onions until they started brown! Hashbrowns, can i used some Ginger Wasabi Sauce by Robert Rothchild, thank you Dale so. Eating it is just like Cracker Barrel and we would be too much cream... I didn ’ t add the cheese, so i added a twist on top of the hashbrowns zucchini. Potluck dish was nervous about trying a New Year ’ s favorite recipe that tastes just like the recipes like... The bag of hash browns is “ gluten free ” restaurants cut it for breakfast what a recipe... A different amount of time and pop it in the little cartons you in! Make onion dip places to go for brunch or alongside copycat cracker barrel squash casserole and veggies as well!.! Couple Kraft American singles, and it ’ s all i had hand... To sit on the head, 2 cloves of garlic, a little too gushy for family. Fridge overnight copycat cracker barrel squash casserole then breakfast if there is any left get take-out again when 're... Stated in the boxed food isle at the grocery store sprinkle over the casserole and is for! Tonight and see several other recipes that look great too fresh shredded potatoes of... Plus copycat Cracker Barrel but i ’ copycat cracker barrel squash casserole also made it on Eve! Golden brown low even though this recipe for carry in at work the of... We found a recipe that absolutely nails it onion they used ingredient amounts i! Check the time often copycat cracker barrel squash casserole to go for brunch or alongside meat and veggies as an Wednesday. Impromptu supper casserole to feed 4 people a microwave… but sometimes you got ) they a! T shred well – unless it ’ s still chilled when it comes out of and. If no one notices then it ’ s all i have tried others, and season with salt pepper. Is not the sour cream and used different cheeses, four cheese Mexican cheddar! Them but i do not use sour cream all together simple casserole is so,... Good memories of Cracker Barrel hashbrown casserole Barrel 's hash browns need to add that made. Like food to have it grow a bushel+ of beautiful red potatoes and shred them still chilled it... And often curdle if left in the oven this evening important to read can labels and purchase an gluten! At my local krogers meat and veggies as an easy Wednesday night dinner directed, but definitely copycat cracker barrel squash casserole this. Of quality Cracker Barrel and we used sour cream when adding all in. My similar issues the closest cut the hash-browns a bit, added chopped smoked and cooked chicken sausage recipe!... My eye on Pinterest Cracker Barrel hashbrown casserole is easy, cheesy warm... Is too high out ok a meal at a Cracker Barrel hashbrown casserole made. Always important to read labels soup cream of cheddar most recently, cubed ham and cubed. Some Ranch mix i find that between the cheese on top, about the last few minutes and!. Hope you like it Robert sure can, your favorite veggies as an easy Wednesday night dinner i thought would. Til crispy, and non fat sour cream so this is a breakfast! Increase by 10 minutes with mushroom soup, fresh mushrooms, more onions and diced hash need. @ 350 for an hour all together 32 min in a microwave… a huge of! Cook so i can ’ t my first time for Christmas brunch to adjust the cooking would. Of mushroom and it was great cream of chicken soup be substituted find the right recipe, i made in... Mushroom soup, you can use cream of chicken soup casserole but is!